Libardi Service Agency is an independent insurance agency in Hicksville, NY that places general liability and umbrella coverage for contractors across New York State, including New York City, Long Island, and upstate. Because New York's Labor Law 240 (the Scaffold Law) and 241 put heavy liability on contractors and owners, many policies exclude or limit these claims. We write contractors who need full Labor Law coverage and contractors who don't, and we match the policy to the work you actually do and the contracts you sign.
Looking for your full contractor program? See our Contractors Insurance page.
Last updated: October 2026
If you own a building in New York or hire people to build, renovate, or demolish one, three state laws sit in the background of almost every serious jobsite injury.
They are Labor Law §240, §241(6), and §200. Lawyers often file all three in the same lawsuit. They sound technical. The idea behind them is not.
New York decided long ago that workers on construction sites should not be left to absorb the cost of a bad fall, a missing guardrail, or an unsafe building condition. These statutes push a large share of that responsibility onto the property owner and the general contractor.
This article explains what each law covers, how they differ, and why they matter even if you never set foot on the job. It is general information, not legal advice.
The short version
Labor Law 240 (the Scaffold Law) covers injuries caused by gravity: a worker falling from a height, or something falling on a worker, when the right safety equipment was missing or did not work. This is New York’s strictest construction law. The injured person’s own partial fault usually does not reduce the award.
Labor Law 241(6) covers construction, demolition, and excavation work that did not follow New York’s written safety code—the Industrial Code. Think slippery floors, debris in a walkway, bad lighting, unsafe ladders, or demolition done the wrong way. The owner and general contractor can still be sued even if they did not personally supervise that task. The worker’s own fault *can* reduce the award.
Labor Law 200 is the “safe workplace” law. It is New York’s version of ordinary negligence on a jobsite. It asks a simpler question: did this person create a dangerous condition, know about it and leave it, or actually tell the crew how to do the work that went wrong?
Workers’ compensation still pays the injured employee’s medical bills and a portion of lost wages through their own employer. These three laws are how that same worker can also sue the *owner and general contractor* for additional damages.
Why New York is different
Most states treat a construction injury like any other accident: prove someone was careless, and reduce the payout if the injured person was partly at fault.
New York kept an older, tougher rule for elevation-related construction injuries. Section 240 is the piece that makes this state unique. Sections 241(6) and 200 fill in everything 240 does not cover.
That combination is why construction projects in New York are more heavily insured, and more expensive to insure, than similar work in other states.
Labor Law 240 — the Scaffold Law
The nickname is misleading. It is not only about scaffolds.
The statute says owners, contractors, and their agents must provide devices—scaffolds, hoists, ladders, ropes, braces, and similar equipment—that are built, placed, and used so they actually protect the worker. It applies to work such as building, demolishing, repairing, altering, painting, cleaning, or pointing a building or structure.
Two kinds of accidents usually fall under 240:
- A worker falls from a ladder, scaffold, roof, beam, or opening.
- A worker is hit by material or equipment that falls because it was not secured or hoisted properly.
There is no magic number of feet in the statute. Courts look at whether height and gravity were a real part of the danger, and whether the right protection was missing.
If those boxes are checked, liability is described as “absolute” or “strict.” In plain terms:
- The owner does not have to have been on site.
- Hiring a reputable contractor does not, by itself, get the owner out.
- The worker’s partial mistake generally does not cut the recovery.
The law is not a blank check for every fall. If proper equipment was provided and the worker’s own conduct was the *only* cause—or the worker refused equipment that was available and required—the claim can fail. Those defenses are narrow.
Homeowners: owners of one- and two-family homes who hire the work but do not direct how it is done are often exempt from Section 240. That exemption disappears if the owner runs the crew, supplies the unsafe equipment, or is really using the property as a business project.
Labor Law 241(6) — the safety-code law
This is the statute for the everyday dangerous jobsite.
It says areas where construction, excavation, or demolition is happening must be set up and run to give workers reasonable protection. The details live in New York’s Industrial Code (mainly Part 23). Those rules get specific: keep walkways clear of debris, clean up substances that make a floor slippery, light the work area, use ladders a certain way, follow demolition and excavation procedures.
To use Section 241(6), the injured person generally has to point to a specific Code rule that applies to what happened—not a vague “be safe” sentence. Courts have spent years drawing that line. A rule that names the hazard *and* says what must be done about it can support a claim. A rule that only says “work carefully” usually cannot.
Federal OSHA rules are not a substitute. The predicate has to come from New York’s Code.
Two features matter if you own the property or run the job:
1. The duty cannot be handed off. The owner and general contractor can be responsible even if a subcontractor was the one who left the mess or used the bad ladder.
2. Unlike Section 240, the injured worker’s own share of fault *can* reduce the money awarded.
That is why housekeeping photos, lighting, ladder checks, and demolition procedures are not busywork. They are the file that later decides a 241(6) claim.
Labor Law 200 — the safe-workplace law
Section 200 restates a simple common-law idea: the people in charge of a workplace should keep it reasonably safe.
It is broader than the other two statutes. It is not limited to construction. It has no special homeowner exemption. In a construction case it almost always travels with a regular negligence claim, and courts treat the two as the same analysis.
The case usually follows one of two paths.
Something was wrong with the place. A rotting staircase, a hole that was already in the floor, ice that was left, debris sitting in a doorway after the trade that left it had moved on. The owner or contractor can be responsible if they created that condition, or knew about it—or should have known about it because it was obvious and had been there long enough—and did not fix it in time.
Something was wrong with how the work was done. The way a load was lifted, a ladder was set, or a wall was taken down. Here the question is control. General walkthroughs, the right to stop work, and a contract sentence that says “the contractor is responsible for safety” are usually not enough. Courts look for actual direction of the specific task that caused the injury.
Section 200 is how a case reaches the party who really created the problem or ran the work—including situations where Section 240 does not fit and no Industrial Code section quite matches.
How the three laws show up in real accidents
A worker slips on diesel on the floor.
Usually 241(6) and 200. Rarely 240. The Code has a specific rule about slippery floors.
Debris or tools left in a hallway.
Usually 241(6) and 200. The argument is often whether it was a “passageway” under the Code and who left it there.
A building stair was already defective before the job started.
Usually 200. The owner’s notice of the condition is the issue. 240 only enters if the defect created a true height-related fall that proper protection would have stopped.
A ladder kicks out.
Often all three. Plaintiffs lead with 240 because partial fault does not reduce that claim. 241(6) adds the ladder rules in the Code. 200 asks who told the worker how to set the ladder.
Lumber or a tool falls from above.
Often 240 first, then 241(6) and 200. After several Court of Appeals cases, the object does not have to fall from many stories.
A machine guard is missing, or demolition is done unsafely, at ground level.
Usually 241(6) and 200. Not 240 unless gravity—a fall or a falling object—is still the heart of the injury.
A homeowner hires a crew on a house they live in.
240 and 241(6) may not apply if the owner stayed out of how the work was done. Section 200 can still apply if the owner created the danger or directed the crew.
What this means if you own property
You can be named in a lawsuit even if you never visited the site. New York puts that duty on owners because they are considered the parties who can insist on safety and carry insurance for it.
You cannot contract that duty away in a sentence that says “the general contractor is solely responsible.” You *can* require the contractor to insure you, indemnify you, and document how the work will be protected. Those papers only help if they match the actual insurance policies—not just a certificate.
If you own a one- or two-family home and you are not running the job, you may have an important exemption from 240 and 241(6). Do not assume it covers a rental property run as a business, a flip, or a job you personally directed.
Section 200 can still apply to a homeowner.
What this means if you are the contractor
You are the usual target on all three statutes.
Section 241(6) is the one that turns ordinary site conditions—housekeeping, lighting, ladders, equipment, demolition—into owner-and-GC liability. Section 240 is the one that turns a fall into a no-comparative-fault case. Section 200 is the one that asks whether *you* actually ran the task.
The practical response is unglamorous and effective: write down the protection that was provided, keep the walkways and lighting in shape, and make sure the people working for you carry insurance that actually responds when their employee is hurt and the owner gets sued. In New York that last piece is called an “action over” claim. The injured worker cannot sue their own employer. They sue you and the owner. The owner’s insurer then looks downstream to the trade that employed the worker.
A note on insurance, in plain language
There is no single policy titled “Labor Law insurance.”
Protection comes from general liability coverage, extra (umbrella) limits, and the endorsements that add the owner or general contractor onto a subcontractor’s policy. Some policies quietly exclude the exact claims these statutes create. A one-page certificate does not show those exclusions.
If you build or renovate in New York, the coverage conversation is not “do I have liability insurance?” It is “does this policy still respond when a worker employed by someone else sues the owner under these statutes?”
Bottom line
If you own property, hire contractors, or run jobs in New York, the useful next step is not memorizing case names. It is making sure the contracts, safety practices, and insurance on the project were built for these three statutes—not for a state that does not have them.
This article summarizes public New York statutes and well-known court interpretations. It is not legal advice. Outcomes depend on the facts of the job and the accident. For the official text, see Labor Law § 240, § 241, and § 200.
