Company Contact Directory
Manage your account, file a claim, or pay a bill directly on your insurance carrier's website. You may need to create an online account if you haven't already.
Find Your Insurance Company Below
Company Payment Details
AFCO Direct - Financing
Payment Phone Number - 877-701-1212; 800-288-6901
Payment Website - https://www.afcodirect.com/borrowers/contact-us
American European
Payment Phone Number - 888-925-7100
Payment Website- https://www.aeiginsurance.com/contact/
Attune
Payment Phone Number - 888-530-4650
Payment Website - https://app.attuneinsurance.com/billing
Blitz Insurance E&S
Payment Phone Number - 877-442-5489
Payment Website - https://www.blitzinsurance.com/
Brite.CO - Jewelry/Event Insurance
Payment Phone Number - 312-809-9100
Payment Website - https://brite.co/contact/
Cabrillo
Payment Phone Number - 866-896-7233
Payment Website - https://cabgen.com/
CNA Central
Payment Phone Number - 877-276-7507
Payment Website - https://www.cna.com/
Coterie Insurance
Payment Phone Number - 855-566-1011
Payment Website - https://coterieinsurance.com/support/
Farmers
Payment Phone Number - 888-327-6335 personal; 855-323-5350 commercial
Payment Website - https://www.farmers.com/contact-us/
ForemostSTAR
Payment Phone Number - 800-532-4221
Payment Website - https://www.foremost.com/
GEICO
Payment Phone Number - 800-841-3000
Payment Website - https://www.geico.com/
Guard
Payment Phone Number - 800-673-2465
Payment Website - https://www.guard.com/payments/
Hanover Insurance Company
Payment Phone Number - 800-573-1187
Payment Website - https://www.hanover.com/
Hartford
Payment Phone Number - 800-624-5578
Payment Website - https://service.thehartford.com/public/index.html#/
Hiscox
Payment Phone Number - 866-283-7545; payment assistance 866-218-4219
Payment Website - https://www.hiscox.com/manage-your-policy
Lancer
Payment Phone Number - 800-782-8902 ext. 3901
Payment Website - https://www.lancerinsurance.com/contact
Main Street America
Payment Phone Number - 866-335-0509 automated payment; 800-258-5310 billing help
Payment Website - https://msainsurance.com/payment-faqs
Merchants Insurance Group
Payment Phone Number - 800-462-8182
Payment Website - https://www.merchantsgroup.com/
Mercury
Payment Phone Number - 800-987-6000
Payment Website - https://www.mercuryinsurance.com/
Narragansett Bay
Payment Phone Number - 800-343-3375
Payment Website - https://www.nbic.com/company/contact-us/
NAT GEN
Payment Phone Number - 888-293-5108 auto; 888-325-1190 homeowners
Payment Website - https://nationalgeneral.com/policyholders/my-policy/
Nationwide
Payment Phone Number - 888-891-0267
Payment Website - https://libardi.com/insurance-company/nationwide-mutual-insurance-company
NYSIF
Payment Phone Number - 833-844-4704 payments; 888-875-5790 customer service
Payment Website - https://ww3.nysif.com/Home/Employer/WCpolicyholder/AboutYourBill/PayMyBill1
Orchid Insurance
Payment Phone Number - 866-370-6505
Payment Website - https://orchidinsurance.com/contact-us/
PHILY INS CO
Payment Phone Number - 877-438-7459
Payment Website - https://www.phly.com/
Pie Insurance
Payment Phone Number - 855-705-2716 workers' comp; 800-438-5374 commercial auto
Payment Website - https://www.pieinsurance.com/about/contact
Plymouth Rock Assurance
Payment Phone Number - 866-353-6292
Payment Website - https://www.plymouthrock.com/
Progressive
Payment Phone Number - 800-876-5581
Payment Website - https://www.progressive.com/manage-policy/
Rainbow Insurance
Payment Phone Number - 888-727-2462 ext. 1
Payment Website - https://www.userainbow.com/company/contact
RoundHill Express
Payment Phone Number - 718-576-2680
Payment Website - https://www.roundhillexpress.com/
SageSure
Payment Phone Number - 800-481-0661
Payment Website - https://www.sagesure.com/customer-service/
ShelterPoint (Formerly First Rehab)
Payment Phone Number - 800-365-4999
Payment Website - https://www.shelterpoint.com/corporate/contactoverview.aspx
ShoreOne Insurance
Payment Phone Number - 833-378-3781
Payment Website - https://www.shoreoneinsurance.com/contact-us
Sterling Insurance
Payment Phone Number - 800-462-4661
Payment Website - https://www.sterlingfi.com/
Thimble Insurance
Payment Phone Number - No public billing phone; chat/email support
Payment Website - https://help.thimble.com/hc/en-us/articles/4401822394259-How-do-I-contact-Thimble
Travelers
Payment Phone Number - 800-842-5075
Payment Website - https://www.travelers.com/pay-your-bill
U S Assure
Payment Phone Number - 855-872-7787
Payment Website - https://usassure.com/customer-support/pay-a-bill
USLI
Payment Phone Number - 866-632-2003
Payment Website - https://www.usli.com/
Utica First
Payment Phone Number - 800-456-4556
Payment Website - https://www.uticafirst.com/
Utica National
Payment Phone Number - 800-598-8422
Payment Website - https://www.uticanational.com/make-a-payment